Ticket #484 (closed assessed: fixed)
EwE5 Database on Ecopath.org fails to import
| Reported by: | shermanl | Owned by: | jeroens |
|---|---|---|---|
| Priority: | normal | Milestone: | Ecopath 6: release 6.0.8 |
| Component: | Database / Import | Version: | |
| Severity: | minor | Keywords: | |
| Cc: |
Description (last modified by shermanl) (diff)
Several database on Ecopath.org fails the import process as you can see in the below email. (http://www.ecopath.org/index.php?name=Models). Here is the list of models that does not work.
Model Name Functional Groups Questions/Issues? Works on version 5.1?
Aleutian_63_2005_Sylvie_80% 40 Diet Composition for Rockfish does not sum up to 1 Yes
Baltic 17 No value for detritus biomass Yes
Chesapeake 46 No value for detritus biomass Yes
CNP 31 Failed to estimate various parameters (EE and biomass) Yes
Eastern_Bering_Sea 26 No value for detritus biomass and failed to estimate various paramenters (EE and biomass) Yes
ETP7 39 Failed to estimate various parameters (EE and biomass) Yes
Iceland_-_1950 24 Failed to estimate various parameters (EE and biomass) Yes
North Sea 32 Failed to estimate various parameters (EE) Yes
SEAK_1963_18mars_PDO2 40 Failed to estimate various parameters (EE) Yes
WCVI 15 No value for detritus biomass Yes
From: csoykan@… csoykan@… Sent: June-18-08 15:23 To: Villy Christensen Subject: Problems running Ecosim with EwE 6
Villy,
Below is a post I added to the EwE 6 bug report on the website ...
however, since it doesn't seem like people check the bug report very often, I thought that I'd email you directly as well:
I am using several EwE models posted on this website ... however, they were created in an earlier version of EwE (5.0 or 5.1) and when I convert them to EwE 6.0 and try to run Ecosim I encounter several problems. These include:
1) The detritus biomass is not defined for several of the models; 2) The diet composition for a group does not sum to 1 for one of the models; and 3) EwE fails to estimate various parameters (EEs and group biomasses) for several of the models.
If I run the models in EwE 5.1, I do not encounter these problems, so I am pretty sure that it has something to do with the new version of EwE or with the conversion of the models from one version to another. Any insights or feedback would be appreciated.
Thanks, Candan Soykan csoykan@…
Change History
comment:3 Changed 15 years ago by jeroens
| Model | Status |
| Aleutian_63_2005_Sylvie_80% (40) | Model not found |
| Baltic (17) | Model not found |
| Chesapeake(46) | Model not found |
| CNP (31) | Model not found |
| Eastern_Bering_Sea (26) | Model not found |
| ETP7 (39) | Model not found |
| Iceland_-_1950 (24) | Fixed |
| North Sea (32) | Model not found |
| SEAK_1963_18mars_PDO2 (40) | Model not found |
| WCVI (15) | Model not found |
comment:4 Changed 15 years ago by shermanl
- Milestone changed from Ecopath 6: build 6.0.7 to Ecopath 6: build 6.0.8
comment:5 Changed 15 years ago by shermanl
- Status changed from assigned to closed
- Resolution changed from open to fixed
All these models are found here (you'll have to open with a later version of 5.1): C:\Ecopath\Ecopath6_Internal_misc\Database\EwE5 Databases\EcopathMSY.zip
| Model | Status |
| Aleutian_63_2005_Sylvie_80% (40) | Model not found |
| Baltic (17) | Balanced (resolved) |
| Chesapeake(46) | Model not balanced (resolved) |
| CNP (31) | Estimated ok (resolved) |
| Eastern_Bering_Sea (26) | Estimated ok (resolved) |
| ETP7 (39) | Estimated ok (resolved) |
| Iceland_-_1950 (24) | (resolved) |
| North Sea (32) | Estimated ok (resolved) |
| SEAK_1963_18mars_PDO2 (40) | Model not found |
| WCVI (15) | Runs, only warning for no value (resolved) |
NOTES!
- the "no value for detritus" just means we can't display relative value in Ecosim. Simple fix is to put 10. These are not bugs.
